HISTORYFORGE
Greek mythology · Hesiod and Homer · 3 min

Which Greek God Are You?

Ten choices from Hesiod, Homer and the Homeric Hymns. Zeus, Hera, Poseidon, Hades, Athena, Apollo, Artemis, Hermes, Aphrodite or Hephaestus. Below the quiz: where the gods actually come from, and how much of the modern version would have surprised a Greek.

Hesiod · Homer · The Hymns · Ten questions

Ten choices the gods actually face in Hesiod, Homer and the Homeric Hymns: a debt that was never paid, a war that is not yours, a child fated to die. Choose what you would do. The quiz tells you which Olympian chose the same.

Where the Greek Gods Come From

There is no Greek bible. What survives is poetry, written down over several centuries by people who disagreed with each other and did not see that as a problem. The oldest and most important are the two epics attributed to Homer, the Iliad and the Odyssey, which took shape around the eighth and seventh centuries BC out of a long oral tradition, and the poems of Hesiod, a farmer-poet from Boeotia working around 700 BC.

Hesiod's Theogony is the closest thing to an official family tree: how the world came out of Chaos, how the sky god Ouranos was castrated by his son Kronos, how Kronos swallowed his own children, and how Zeus escaped, overthrew him and the Titans, and shared out the world. His Works and Days adds Prometheus, Pandora and a hard-headed view of justice. The Homeric Hymns, thirty-odd poems in Homer's style composed mostly in the seventh and sixth centuries BC, give single gods their own stories: Demeter searching for Persephone, the birth of Apollo, Hermes stealing cattle on the day he was born.

Everything after that is retelling. The Athenian tragedians of the fifth century BC reworked the myths for the stage. A mythographer known as Apollodorus compiled a handbook under the Roman Empire. And many of the most famous stories, including Arachne, Echo and Narcissus, and Apollo and Daphne, reach us in their best-known form from the Roman poet Ovid's Metamorphoses, finished around AD 8, some seven centuries after Hesiod.

The Gods Were Older Than Homer

The gods were already old by the time anyone wrote poems about them. Clay tablets in Linear B, the script of the Mycenaean palaces, survived because the fires that destroyed those palaces around 1200 BC baked them hard. They record offerings to Zeus, Hera, Poseidon and Hermes, to a goddess called the Mistress of Atana, and to Dionysus, who is often described as a late arrival in Greece. At Pylos, Poseidon seems to have been the most important god of all. Homer was singing about a world that had been gone for four or five centuries.

Zeus Took Power by Force

Hesiod's account of how Zeus became king is not gentle. Kronos, warned that a son would overthrow him as he had overthrown his own father, swallowed each of his children as they were born. Rhea hid the last, Zeus, on Crete and handed Kronos a stone wrapped in swaddling clothes instead. Grown, Zeus made his father vomit up his brothers and sisters, fought the Titans for ten years, and imprisoned them in Tartarus. When the same prophecy was made about his own first wife, Metis, Zeus solved it by swallowing her.

Homer adds the division of the world. In Iliad 15 Poseidon explains that the three sons of Kronos drew lots: Zeus took the sky, Poseidon the sea and Hades the gloom below, with the earth and Olympus held in common. Poseidon is not happy about how that turned out. Zeus is plainly the strongest god in the Iliad, and in Book 8 he boasts that if all the others took hold of a golden chain and pulled, they could not drag him down, while he could haul them up, earth and sea and all. Yet he is constantly bargained with, deceived and argued round, most of all by Hera.

Gods Who Bleed, Lose and Laugh

The Homeric gods are not dignified. In Iliad 5 the mortal Diomedes wounds Aphrodite in the hand and then, with Athena guiding his spear, wounds Ares, who runs to Olympus to complain and is told by Zeus that he is the most hateful of all the gods. In Iliad 21 the gods fight one another on the plain of Troy: Athena knocks Ares down with a boulder, Hera boxes Artemis's ears with her own bow, and Hermes politely declines to fight at all. In Odyssey 8 a bard sings of Hephaestus catching Aphrodite and Ares in bed with an invisible net, and the gods who come to look break into what Homer calls unquenchable laughter.

Greeks were bothered by this too. In the sixth century BC the philosopher Xenophanes complained that Homer and Hesiod had pinned on the gods everything that is shameful among humans: theft, adultery and deceiving one another. Plato later wanted those passages kept away from the young. The gods of Greek religion, who received sacrifices and answered prayers, and the gods of Greek poetry, who misbehaved, were always in an uneasy partnership. The temples were real. For what the Greeks did when their own world was at stake, see the Battle of Thermopylae.

The Stories Were Not the Religion

It is easy to forget that these gods were worshipped, not only told about. Greek religion centred on sacrifice at outdoor altars, on festivals fixed to each city's calendar, and on sanctuaries that drew people from across the Greek world. Olympia held games in honour of Zeus every four years from, by tradition, 776 BC. At Delphi, Apollo spoke through a priestess called the Pythia, and cities consulted her before founding colonies or going to war. Athens built the Parthenon for Athena, and at its greatest festival, the Panathenaia, presented a new robe to her ancient olive-wood statue.

None of that required anyone to take the Iliad literally. Herodotus, writing in the fifth century BC, says it was Homer and Hesiod who gave the Greeks their account of the gods' origins, named them, divided their honours and described their shapes, and that the two poets lived no more than four hundred years before his own time. In other words, even a Greek knew the stories had authors.

What the Sources Say, and What You Have Seen

  • Hades is the villain. In the sources he is grim and unyielding, and he keeps to his own realm. Apart from carrying off Persephone, with Zeus's consent, he barely leaves it. The plotting underworld god of films is a modern creation.
  • Hera is the mother of Heracles. The opposite. Heracles was Zeus's son by a mortal woman, Alcmene, and Hera persecuted him from before he was born. That his name seems to mean glory of Hera is one of the oddities of Greek myth.
  • Aphrodite is the daughter of Zeus. Only in Homer. In Hesiod she is older than Zeus, born from the sea foam after Kronos castrated Ouranos.
  • There were always the same twelve Olympians. The number twelve was fairly stable; the names were not. Lists differ, and Hestia and Dionysus in particular come and go. Among the seated gods on the east frieze of the Parthenon, Dionysus is there and Hestia is not.
  • Pandora's box. In Hesiod she opens a jar, a large storage vessel. The box comes from a sixteenth-century mistranslation by Erasmus.

Who Is Missing From the Quiz

Ten gods are here. Three major ones are not. Demeter, whose grief for Persephone is the heart of the Homeric Hymn to Demeter, mostly appears in that one story. Dionysus, god of wine and ecstasy, belongs to tragedy more than epic, above all Euripides' Bacchae. Ares is in Homer constantly, but almost only to lose, bleed and be scolded. And Hestia, goddess of the hearth, was honoured at nearly every sacrifice and appears in almost no stories at all, which may be the most Greek thing about her.

Questions

Is this quiz based on Percy Jackson or the films?+

No. Every answer is a choice one of the gods makes in Hesiod, Homer or the Homeric Hymns, with the god's name left out. Where a result mentions a later story, it says it is later. Each result names where to read that god.

How does the quiz pick my god?+

Each answer gives two points to the god whose choice it is and one point to a second god it also fits. The highest total wins. We checked all 1,048,576 possible combinations of answers: each of the ten gods comes out between about 9 and 11 percent of the time, so no result is rare.

Sources

  • ·Homer, Iliad and Odyssey (8th to 7th century BC)
  • ·Hesiod, Theogony and Works and Days (c. 700 BC)
  • ·The Homeric Hymns, especially those to Demeter, Apollo, Hermes and Aphrodite (7th to 6th century BC)
  • ·Linear B tablets from Pylos and Knossos (c. 1400 to 1200 BC)
  • ·Xenophanes, fragment B11; Plato, Republic Books 2 and 3
  • ·Herodotus, Histories 2.53, 7.26 and 8.55
  • ·Euripides, Hippolytus (428 BC) and Bacchae (405 BC)
  • ·Ovid, Metamorphoses (c. AD 8), for the later Roman versions
  • ·M. L. West (trans.), Hesiod, Theogony and Works and Days, Oxford World's Classics
  • ·Walter Burkert, Greek Religion (English translation 1985)
  • ·John Chadwick, The Mycenaean World (1976)
Play history instead of reading it

The gods are myth, but the world that worshipped them was real. HistoryForge puts you inside real history as someone living through it, and your decisions shape what happens. These are playable today.