HISTORYFORGE
Norse mythology · The Eddas · 3 min

Which Norse God Are You?

Ten choices from the Poetic and Prose Edda. Odin, Thor, Loki, Tyr, Freyja, Frigg, Heimdall or Freyr. Below the quiz: who each of them was in the sources, and how much of what you think you know comes from one thirteenth-century Icelander.

The Eddas · Ten questions

Ten choices the gods actually face in the Poetic Edda and Snorri's Prose Edda: a stolen hammer, a wall built on a bad bargain, a wolf that wants a hand as surety. Choose what you would do. The quiz tells you which god chose the same.

Where the Norse Gods Actually Come From

Almost everything anyone knows about the Norse gods comes from two books written in Iceland in the thirteenth century, more than two hundred years after Iceland accepted Christianity around the year 1000. Neither was written by a believer.

The Poetic Edda is a collection of anonymous poems preserved in a single manuscript, the Codex Regius, copied around 1270 and rediscovered in 1643 by an Icelandic bishop. Some of its poems may be centuries older than the manuscript, and how much older is one of the longest arguments in the field. It contains Völuspá, a seeress's account of the world from creation to Ragnarök; Hávamál, the sayings of Odin; and a run of comic and violent poems about Thor and Loki.

The Prose Edda was written around 1220 by Snorri Sturluson, an Icelandic chieftain, lawspeaker and politician, as a handbook for poets. Skaldic poetry was built on allusions to myth, and Snorri worried the allusions were being forgotten. He organised the stories, filled gaps, quoted poems that are otherwise lost, and wrapped it all in a Christian frame: his prologue explains the gods as human kings from Troy whom later people mistook for gods. When the two Eddas disagree, Snorri is usually the one tidying things up.

Around them sit a handful of other witnesses. Skaldic verse composed for Viking Age rulers. Saxo Grammaticus, a Danish cleric writing in Latin around 1200, who treats the gods as clever humans. The German chronicler Adam of Bremen, writing in the 1070s, who described a temple at Uppsala with statues of Thor, Wodan and Fricco. Runestones that ask Thor to hallow the runes. Place names, hammer pendants and carved picture stones. None of this adds up to a pagan scripture, because there never was one. For the Viking Age itself, rather than its gods, see our history of the raid on Lindisfarne.

Two Families of Gods

The gods come in two families. The Æsir, the larger group, include Odin, Thor, Tyr, Frigg, Baldr and Heimdall. The Vanir, linked with fertility, wealth and the sea, include Njörðr and his children Freyr and Freyja. Völuspá calls their conflict the first war in the world, and says it began when the Æsir tried three times to burn a woman named Gullveig, who three times came back to life.

The war ended in a truce and an exchange of hostages. Snorri's Ynglinga saga says the Vanir sent Njörðr and Freyr, and the Æsir sent Hœnir and the wise Mímir. The Vanir, deciding they had been cheated, cut off Mímir's head and sent it back, and Odin preserved it with herbs and spells so that it could go on advising him. That exchange is why the goddess of love, magic and the battle dead is a Van. Freyja, Snorri says, was the one who taught seiðr to the Æsir.

Odin Is Not a Kindly Old King

Odin is the chief of the gods in Snorri, but he is not a benevolent father, and the poems do not pretend he is. He is a god of war, poetry, the dead, magic and frenzy. He gives victory and takes it away. In Lokasenna Loki accuses him of handing victory to cowards, and in the sagas warriors who trusted him are sometimes abandoned at the worst moment.

What drives him is knowledge, and the price is always some part of himself. He pledges an eye at Mímir's well. He hangs on a tree for nine nights, pierced with a spear, a sacrifice of himself to himself, to win the runes. He travels the worlds under false names, wagers his head in a contest of wisdom with a giant in Vafþrúðnismál, and in Baldrs draumar rides down to the dead to wake a seeress and ask about his son's fate. He knows from Völuspá how it all ends: at Ragnarök the wolf Fenrir kills him. The warriors he gathers in Valhalla are his preparation for a battle he already knows he will lose.

Thor Was the God People Actually Prayed To

Ask an ordinary Norse farmer which god mattered most and the answer was probably Thor. Adam of Bremen says his statue stood in the middle of the Uppsala temple, between Wodan and Fricco, and that he ruled thunder, lightning, winds, rain, fair weather and crops. Thor turns up everywhere in names, of places and of people: Thorstein, Thorgerd, Thorkel. Small hammer pendants were worn so widely that a soapstone mould found in Denmark was made to cast hammers and crosses side by side.

The myths make him the defender of gods and humans against the giants, and also their best comic character. In Þrymskviða he has to dress as a bride to get his hammer back. In Hárbarðsljóð a ferryman, who is Odin in disguise, refuses to row him across a river and insults him for an entire poem. In Hymiskviða he goes fishing with an ox's head for bait and hooks the world serpent; in Snorri's telling the terrified giant in the boat cuts the line. That fishing scene was carved on stones in Sweden, Denmark and northern England, one of the clearest signs that these stories were being told long before anyone wrote them down.

Loki Is Not Odin's Son

Loki is the best-known Norse figure today and the most puzzling one in the sources. He is not Odin's son or Thor's brother. Snorri gives his father as the giant Fárbauti, and in Lokasenna Loki reminds Odin that the two of them mixed their blood in the old days and swore to drink only together. He lives among the gods, travels with Thor, and gets them out of trouble almost as often as he gets them into it.

Across the myths he changes. In the early stories he is a trickster whose schemes produce the gods' treasures and the eight-legged horse Sleipnir. Then he fathers, with the giantess Angrboða, the wolf Fenrir, the world serpent and Hel, ruler of the dead. He brings about the death of Baldr. He is bound under the earth until Ragnarök, when Völuspá has him steering a ship of the gods' enemies against them. Scholars have argued for two centuries about what he originally was, because there is no sign that anyone ever worshipped him: no place names, no personal names, no cult. He seems to have lived only in stories.

The Goddesses Most Retellings Leave Out

Freyja and Frigg get less attention than they deserve, partly because the surviving poems are mostly about male gods. Freyja is a goddess of love and sex, but also of war and magic: she takes half of the battle dead, as Odin takes the other half. Frigg is Odin's wife and Baldr's mother, and in Lokasenna Freyja warns that Frigg knows all fates, though she does not speak of them. Scholars have long debated whether the two began as a single goddess, since the older Germanic Frija, who probably gave her name to Friday, covers parts of both.

Their best stories are about refusing to be managed. Freyja turns down the giant Þrymr's marriage demand so furiously that her necklace snaps. Frigg, in a legend about the Lombards written down in the seventh century and retold by Paul the Deacon a century later, gets her way with Odin by turning his bed around in the night. Paul, a Christian monk, calls the story ridiculous, and then records it anyway.

What the Sources Say, and What You Have Seen

  • Loki is Thor's adopted brother. Not in any source. He is Odin's sworn blood-brother, born of giants, and Thor's travelling companion.
  • Every fallen warrior goes to Valhalla. Grímnismál sends half of the battle dead to Freyja's hall, Fólkvangr, and Snorri sends those who die of sickness or old age to Hel.
  • Thor is blond. Where the sagas describe him, he has a red beard.
  • Ragnarök is the end of everything. Völuspá goes on past it. The earth rises green from the sea, Baldr returns from the dead, and the surviving gods find their old golden game pieces lying in the grass. Some scholars hear Christian influence in that ending; others think it is older. Nobody can prove either.

Questions

Is this quiz based on the Marvel films?+

No. Every answer is a choice one of the gods makes in the Poetic Edda, Snorri Sturluson's Prose Edda or his Ynglinga saga, with the god's name left out. Each result says where to read that god's stories.

How does the quiz pick my god?+

Each answer gives two points to the god whose choice it is and one point to a second god it also fits. The highest total wins. We checked all 1,048,576 possible combinations of answers: each of the eight gods comes out between about 12 and 14 percent of the time, so no result is rare.

Why are Baldr and Hel not results?+

The eight gods here are the ones the sources show making choices. Baldr is mostly someone things happen to, and Hel appears in only a few scenes. Both feature in the write-ups of the gods around them.

Sources

  • ·The Poetic Edda (Codex Regius, copied c. 1270): Völuspá, Hávamál, Grímnismál, Vafþrúðnismál, Lokasenna, Þrymskviða, Hymiskviða, Hárbarðsljóð, Skírnismál, Rígsþula, Baldrs draumar
  • ·Snorri Sturluson, Prose Edda (c. 1220): Gylfaginning and Skáldskaparmál
  • ·Snorri Sturluson, Ynglinga saga, in Heimskringla (c. 1230)
  • ·Adam of Bremen, Deeds of the Bishops of Hamburg, Book 4 (1070s), on the temple at Uppsala
  • ·Origo Gentis Langobardorum (7th century) and Paul the Deacon, History of the Lombards 1.8 (late 8th century)
  • ·Saxo Grammaticus, Gesta Danorum (c. 1200)
  • ·Carolyne Larrington (trans.), The Poetic Edda, Oxford World's Classics
  • ·Anthony Faulkes (trans.), Snorri Sturluson, Edda, Everyman
  • ·John Lindow, Norse Mythology: A Guide to the Gods, Heroes, Rituals, and Beliefs (2001)
Play history instead of reading it

These are myths, but the people who told them lived through real history. HistoryForge puts you inside that history as someone living through it, and your decisions shape what happens. These are playable today.